What exactly is the meaning of “fine wine”?meaning of 'over'How to interpret the verb 'trace' to...
A vote on the Brexit backstop
Does an unused member variable take up memory?
Was it really inappropriate to write a pull request for the company I interviewed with?
How to distinguish easily different soldier of ww2?
Giving a talk in my old university, how prominently should I tell students my salary?
PTIJ: Sport in the Torah
I am the person who abides by rules but breaks the rules . Who am I
3.5% Interest Student Loan or use all of my savings on Tuition?
How spaceships determine each other's mass in space?
Is it a Cyclops number? "Nobody" knows!
Why aren't there more Gauls like Obelix?
Why is there an extra space when I type "ls" on the Desktop?
Generating a list with duplicate entries
How to write a chaotic neutral protagonist and prevent my readers from thinking they are evil?
Why isn't P and P/poly trivially the same?
What is 'Log Memory' in Query Store 2017
Paper published similar to PhD thesis
Help! My Character is too much for her story!
Can Witch Sight see through Mirror Image?
Mixed Feelings - What am I
What is better: yes / no radio, or simple checkbox?
Who has more? Ireland or Iceland?
Limpar string com Regex
How to make sure I'm assertive enough in contact with subordinates?
What exactly is the meaning of “fine wine”?
meaning of 'over'How to interpret the verb 'trace' to determine the relevant 'Kantian notions'?What does “the brass” mean, exactly, in military context?What does “all-in” mean in this context?meaning of “deli”, or what a deli sellsmeaning of “weaning the faithful from the vine”meaning of “nayles”What is the meaning of 'He rested for final qualifier'the meaning of “this Oscar-tipped production”Meaning of “since” and “pending” in a news article
I read an article which was titled as:
Ageing like fine wine
I'm sill pondering over what does it mean? And, where does it trace it's origin from?
For context, the article talks about a person's achievement?
meaning-in-context
add a comment |
I read an article which was titled as:
Ageing like fine wine
I'm sill pondering over what does it mean? And, where does it trace it's origin from?
For context, the article talks about a person's achievement?
meaning-in-context
2
"Fine" is used in the sense of "excellent" there. A fine wine is one that is exceptionally good.
– Robusto
14 hours ago
"fine wine" is more than £20 a bottle.
– Owain
13 hours ago
4
@Owain In undergrad, fine wine came in a bottle
– Punintended
10 hours ago
3
This is one of those words that can mean its near opposite depending on usage. Compare "This is a fine wine" to "This wine is fine". The first implies that it is of exceptional quality, while the second implies that it is merely acceptable. The English language is screwy that way.
– Darrel Hoffman
7 hours ago
add a comment |
I read an article which was titled as:
Ageing like fine wine
I'm sill pondering over what does it mean? And, where does it trace it's origin from?
For context, the article talks about a person's achievement?
meaning-in-context
I read an article which was titled as:
Ageing like fine wine
I'm sill pondering over what does it mean? And, where does it trace it's origin from?
For context, the article talks about a person's achievement?
meaning-in-context
meaning-in-context
asked 14 hours ago
Vishal GhulatiVishal Ghulati
39518
39518
2
"Fine" is used in the sense of "excellent" there. A fine wine is one that is exceptionally good.
– Robusto
14 hours ago
"fine wine" is more than £20 a bottle.
– Owain
13 hours ago
4
@Owain In undergrad, fine wine came in a bottle
– Punintended
10 hours ago
3
This is one of those words that can mean its near opposite depending on usage. Compare "This is a fine wine" to "This wine is fine". The first implies that it is of exceptional quality, while the second implies that it is merely acceptable. The English language is screwy that way.
– Darrel Hoffman
7 hours ago
add a comment |
2
"Fine" is used in the sense of "excellent" there. A fine wine is one that is exceptionally good.
– Robusto
14 hours ago
"fine wine" is more than £20 a bottle.
– Owain
13 hours ago
4
@Owain In undergrad, fine wine came in a bottle
– Punintended
10 hours ago
3
This is one of those words that can mean its near opposite depending on usage. Compare "This is a fine wine" to "This wine is fine". The first implies that it is of exceptional quality, while the second implies that it is merely acceptable. The English language is screwy that way.
– Darrel Hoffman
7 hours ago
2
2
"Fine" is used in the sense of "excellent" there. A fine wine is one that is exceptionally good.
– Robusto
14 hours ago
"Fine" is used in the sense of "excellent" there. A fine wine is one that is exceptionally good.
– Robusto
14 hours ago
"fine wine" is more than £20 a bottle.
– Owain
13 hours ago
"fine wine" is more than £20 a bottle.
– Owain
13 hours ago
4
4
@Owain In undergrad, fine wine came in a bottle
– Punintended
10 hours ago
@Owain In undergrad, fine wine came in a bottle
– Punintended
10 hours ago
3
3
This is one of those words that can mean its near opposite depending on usage. Compare "This is a fine wine" to "This wine is fine". The first implies that it is of exceptional quality, while the second implies that it is merely acceptable. The English language is screwy that way.
– Darrel Hoffman
7 hours ago
This is one of those words that can mean its near opposite depending on usage. Compare "This is a fine wine" to "This wine is fine". The first implies that it is of exceptional quality, while the second implies that it is merely acceptable. The English language is screwy that way.
– Darrel Hoffman
7 hours ago
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
A good wine supposedly gets better with age. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aging_of_wine
If this expression is used to describe a person (“aging like a fine wine”) it is meant to compliment the person, saying the more they age, the better they become as a person, like a wine (and unlike most other things, which get worse with age).
3
Yes - it's particularly relevant that the wine gets even better with age. And in fact, some kinds of wine (Rioja and other wines based on Garnacha or Tempranillo grape varieties come to mind) aren't actually particularly palatable until they've been adequately aged.
– FumbleFingers
14 hours ago
Then, shouldn't it be just wine without "fine" preceding it ?
– Vishal Ghulati
11 hours ago
7
@Vishal Ghulati no, “fine wine” means a very good (and probably very expensive) wine, as noted in other comments. Fine wines are intentionally aged and get better over time. Mediocre/cheap wines do not improve with age in the same way.
– Mixolydian
11 hours ago
1
"Aging like (spoiled) milk" is the idiom's inverse I usually see.
– Nick T
9 hours ago
Neve heard that one but I understand the implication!
– Mixolydian
9 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
To add to the existing excellent answer from Mixolydian, you may also be interested in the ultimate origin of fine. Etymologists don't seem to be 100% sure, but it seems to come from the same Latin root as finished, and was originally meant as complete, well-rounded, or indeed well-finished.
"Fine wine" typically means the best sorts of wine, though exactly what that means is subjective - though wine critics largely agree in practice. It also means they will be more expensive. I have heard it said that a truly fine wine is such a different experience from a typical supermarket wine that they do not really compare, not any more than wine to grape juice. I have never had what anyone would call a fine wine - and fine wines tend to be red more often than white, in my limited experience, so my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine. I did once have a wine that was supermarket price, but superior to anything I've had before or since - including the next year's vintage from the same vineyard. If that's one tenth of the difference between typical wines and fine wines, then I can see why people pay a lot of money for them.
Whatever it is that makes a wine "fine" also tends to affect how it develops after bottling. Wines being produced for the supermarket or local wine shop are intended to be drunk after a short, set aging period, and are as good as they will get when you buy them - and after a few years, they will degrade. Wines that are being made to be as good as they can get them take far longer to "peak" - to reach their optimum drinking quality. Wine buffs even put a lot of effort into working out when it will be, or knowing when it has happened so they can drink it as soon after peaking as possible. Of course, one bottle won't age the same as another if they are kept in different conditions.
So, fine wines, unlike most foods or drinks, get better when they age, at least up to a point. To say something, or someone, has aged like a fine wine is to say that they have improved with age.
"my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine" Well, it is common when tasting wine to spit it out.
– Acccumulation
8 hours ago
You can't properly appreciate a wine just by tasting it. Plus some would get swallowed, it's inevitable.
– SamBC
7 hours ago
add a comment |
This seems to be a pretty complicated question. Most wines actually don't age well at all. Only some wines age well, and it's not really true that wines that are more expensive before they are aged are the ones that age better. The aging process itself is expensive, so aged wines don't necessarily cost more because of the costs of growing those varietals or costs of making the wine from the grapes, it's the aging itself that drives up the cost.
The other tricky aspect of this question is the word fine. It doesn't just mean "good", especially in the area of wine-making. There is a process that is sometimes done to wine called fining, which is adding any of several substances that captures certain solutes and suspended substances in the wine and causes them to precipitate out.
So is it really that wine that has been fined ages better? Well not so fast, because over fining of wine can make it age more poorly, since some of the solutes that would be caused to precipitate by fining, like tannins, contribute to improvement of the wine when it's aged.
Very few wines improve with age, but those that do can become far more subtle and complex than unaged single-varietal wines, and while blends can be much more complex than single-varietals, an aged wine can have flavors that don't seem to be present in any kind of unaged wine. Then again, wines that age well often aren't very good when they have not yet been aged. Would they be called "fine" as in "good" before they have been aged? Probably not. At the same time, wine that ages well and has been well-aged, can easily be some of the best wine, and it makes sense to call it "fine wine" after it's been aged.
One possibility is that the phrase is just poetry. "Fine" and "wine" rhyme - and "aged like fine wine" rolls off the tongue quite well. Or it could spring from a misunderstanding of what it means for a wine to age well or be well-suited for aging. Even wine aficionados don't all agree on what "fine wine" means.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "481"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fell.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f199686%2fwhat-exactly-is-the-meaning-of-fine-wine%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
A good wine supposedly gets better with age. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aging_of_wine
If this expression is used to describe a person (“aging like a fine wine”) it is meant to compliment the person, saying the more they age, the better they become as a person, like a wine (and unlike most other things, which get worse with age).
3
Yes - it's particularly relevant that the wine gets even better with age. And in fact, some kinds of wine (Rioja and other wines based on Garnacha or Tempranillo grape varieties come to mind) aren't actually particularly palatable until they've been adequately aged.
– FumbleFingers
14 hours ago
Then, shouldn't it be just wine without "fine" preceding it ?
– Vishal Ghulati
11 hours ago
7
@Vishal Ghulati no, “fine wine” means a very good (and probably very expensive) wine, as noted in other comments. Fine wines are intentionally aged and get better over time. Mediocre/cheap wines do not improve with age in the same way.
– Mixolydian
11 hours ago
1
"Aging like (spoiled) milk" is the idiom's inverse I usually see.
– Nick T
9 hours ago
Neve heard that one but I understand the implication!
– Mixolydian
9 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
A good wine supposedly gets better with age. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aging_of_wine
If this expression is used to describe a person (“aging like a fine wine”) it is meant to compliment the person, saying the more they age, the better they become as a person, like a wine (and unlike most other things, which get worse with age).
3
Yes - it's particularly relevant that the wine gets even better with age. And in fact, some kinds of wine (Rioja and other wines based on Garnacha or Tempranillo grape varieties come to mind) aren't actually particularly palatable until they've been adequately aged.
– FumbleFingers
14 hours ago
Then, shouldn't it be just wine without "fine" preceding it ?
– Vishal Ghulati
11 hours ago
7
@Vishal Ghulati no, “fine wine” means a very good (and probably very expensive) wine, as noted in other comments. Fine wines are intentionally aged and get better over time. Mediocre/cheap wines do not improve with age in the same way.
– Mixolydian
11 hours ago
1
"Aging like (spoiled) milk" is the idiom's inverse I usually see.
– Nick T
9 hours ago
Neve heard that one but I understand the implication!
– Mixolydian
9 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
A good wine supposedly gets better with age. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aging_of_wine
If this expression is used to describe a person (“aging like a fine wine”) it is meant to compliment the person, saying the more they age, the better they become as a person, like a wine (and unlike most other things, which get worse with age).
A good wine supposedly gets better with age. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aging_of_wine
If this expression is used to describe a person (“aging like a fine wine”) it is meant to compliment the person, saying the more they age, the better they become as a person, like a wine (and unlike most other things, which get worse with age).
answered 14 hours ago
MixolydianMixolydian
2,226511
2,226511
3
Yes - it's particularly relevant that the wine gets even better with age. And in fact, some kinds of wine (Rioja and other wines based on Garnacha or Tempranillo grape varieties come to mind) aren't actually particularly palatable until they've been adequately aged.
– FumbleFingers
14 hours ago
Then, shouldn't it be just wine without "fine" preceding it ?
– Vishal Ghulati
11 hours ago
7
@Vishal Ghulati no, “fine wine” means a very good (and probably very expensive) wine, as noted in other comments. Fine wines are intentionally aged and get better over time. Mediocre/cheap wines do not improve with age in the same way.
– Mixolydian
11 hours ago
1
"Aging like (spoiled) milk" is the idiom's inverse I usually see.
– Nick T
9 hours ago
Neve heard that one but I understand the implication!
– Mixolydian
9 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
3
Yes - it's particularly relevant that the wine gets even better with age. And in fact, some kinds of wine (Rioja and other wines based on Garnacha or Tempranillo grape varieties come to mind) aren't actually particularly palatable until they've been adequately aged.
– FumbleFingers
14 hours ago
Then, shouldn't it be just wine without "fine" preceding it ?
– Vishal Ghulati
11 hours ago
7
@Vishal Ghulati no, “fine wine” means a very good (and probably very expensive) wine, as noted in other comments. Fine wines are intentionally aged and get better over time. Mediocre/cheap wines do not improve with age in the same way.
– Mixolydian
11 hours ago
1
"Aging like (spoiled) milk" is the idiom's inverse I usually see.
– Nick T
9 hours ago
Neve heard that one but I understand the implication!
– Mixolydian
9 hours ago
3
3
Yes - it's particularly relevant that the wine gets even better with age. And in fact, some kinds of wine (Rioja and other wines based on Garnacha or Tempranillo grape varieties come to mind) aren't actually particularly palatable until they've been adequately aged.
– FumbleFingers
14 hours ago
Yes - it's particularly relevant that the wine gets even better with age. And in fact, some kinds of wine (Rioja and other wines based on Garnacha or Tempranillo grape varieties come to mind) aren't actually particularly palatable until they've been adequately aged.
– FumbleFingers
14 hours ago
Then, shouldn't it be just wine without "fine" preceding it ?
– Vishal Ghulati
11 hours ago
Then, shouldn't it be just wine without "fine" preceding it ?
– Vishal Ghulati
11 hours ago
7
7
@Vishal Ghulati no, “fine wine” means a very good (and probably very expensive) wine, as noted in other comments. Fine wines are intentionally aged and get better over time. Mediocre/cheap wines do not improve with age in the same way.
– Mixolydian
11 hours ago
@Vishal Ghulati no, “fine wine” means a very good (and probably very expensive) wine, as noted in other comments. Fine wines are intentionally aged and get better over time. Mediocre/cheap wines do not improve with age in the same way.
– Mixolydian
11 hours ago
1
1
"Aging like (spoiled) milk" is the idiom's inverse I usually see.
– Nick T
9 hours ago
"Aging like (spoiled) milk" is the idiom's inverse I usually see.
– Nick T
9 hours ago
Neve heard that one but I understand the implication!
– Mixolydian
9 hours ago
Neve heard that one but I understand the implication!
– Mixolydian
9 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
To add to the existing excellent answer from Mixolydian, you may also be interested in the ultimate origin of fine. Etymologists don't seem to be 100% sure, but it seems to come from the same Latin root as finished, and was originally meant as complete, well-rounded, or indeed well-finished.
"Fine wine" typically means the best sorts of wine, though exactly what that means is subjective - though wine critics largely agree in practice. It also means they will be more expensive. I have heard it said that a truly fine wine is such a different experience from a typical supermarket wine that they do not really compare, not any more than wine to grape juice. I have never had what anyone would call a fine wine - and fine wines tend to be red more often than white, in my limited experience, so my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine. I did once have a wine that was supermarket price, but superior to anything I've had before or since - including the next year's vintage from the same vineyard. If that's one tenth of the difference between typical wines and fine wines, then I can see why people pay a lot of money for them.
Whatever it is that makes a wine "fine" also tends to affect how it develops after bottling. Wines being produced for the supermarket or local wine shop are intended to be drunk after a short, set aging period, and are as good as they will get when you buy them - and after a few years, they will degrade. Wines that are being made to be as good as they can get them take far longer to "peak" - to reach their optimum drinking quality. Wine buffs even put a lot of effort into working out when it will be, or knowing when it has happened so they can drink it as soon after peaking as possible. Of course, one bottle won't age the same as another if they are kept in different conditions.
So, fine wines, unlike most foods or drinks, get better when they age, at least up to a point. To say something, or someone, has aged like a fine wine is to say that they have improved with age.
"my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine" Well, it is common when tasting wine to spit it out.
– Acccumulation
8 hours ago
You can't properly appreciate a wine just by tasting it. Plus some would get swallowed, it's inevitable.
– SamBC
7 hours ago
add a comment |
To add to the existing excellent answer from Mixolydian, you may also be interested in the ultimate origin of fine. Etymologists don't seem to be 100% sure, but it seems to come from the same Latin root as finished, and was originally meant as complete, well-rounded, or indeed well-finished.
"Fine wine" typically means the best sorts of wine, though exactly what that means is subjective - though wine critics largely agree in practice. It also means they will be more expensive. I have heard it said that a truly fine wine is such a different experience from a typical supermarket wine that they do not really compare, not any more than wine to grape juice. I have never had what anyone would call a fine wine - and fine wines tend to be red more often than white, in my limited experience, so my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine. I did once have a wine that was supermarket price, but superior to anything I've had before or since - including the next year's vintage from the same vineyard. If that's one tenth of the difference between typical wines and fine wines, then I can see why people pay a lot of money for them.
Whatever it is that makes a wine "fine" also tends to affect how it develops after bottling. Wines being produced for the supermarket or local wine shop are intended to be drunk after a short, set aging period, and are as good as they will get when you buy them - and after a few years, they will degrade. Wines that are being made to be as good as they can get them take far longer to "peak" - to reach their optimum drinking quality. Wine buffs even put a lot of effort into working out when it will be, or knowing when it has happened so they can drink it as soon after peaking as possible. Of course, one bottle won't age the same as another if they are kept in different conditions.
So, fine wines, unlike most foods or drinks, get better when they age, at least up to a point. To say something, or someone, has aged like a fine wine is to say that they have improved with age.
"my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine" Well, it is common when tasting wine to spit it out.
– Acccumulation
8 hours ago
You can't properly appreciate a wine just by tasting it. Plus some would get swallowed, it's inevitable.
– SamBC
7 hours ago
add a comment |
To add to the existing excellent answer from Mixolydian, you may also be interested in the ultimate origin of fine. Etymologists don't seem to be 100% sure, but it seems to come from the same Latin root as finished, and was originally meant as complete, well-rounded, or indeed well-finished.
"Fine wine" typically means the best sorts of wine, though exactly what that means is subjective - though wine critics largely agree in practice. It also means they will be more expensive. I have heard it said that a truly fine wine is such a different experience from a typical supermarket wine that they do not really compare, not any more than wine to grape juice. I have never had what anyone would call a fine wine - and fine wines tend to be red more often than white, in my limited experience, so my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine. I did once have a wine that was supermarket price, but superior to anything I've had before or since - including the next year's vintage from the same vineyard. If that's one tenth of the difference between typical wines and fine wines, then I can see why people pay a lot of money for them.
Whatever it is that makes a wine "fine" also tends to affect how it develops after bottling. Wines being produced for the supermarket or local wine shop are intended to be drunk after a short, set aging period, and are as good as they will get when you buy them - and after a few years, they will degrade. Wines that are being made to be as good as they can get them take far longer to "peak" - to reach their optimum drinking quality. Wine buffs even put a lot of effort into working out when it will be, or knowing when it has happened so they can drink it as soon after peaking as possible. Of course, one bottle won't age the same as another if they are kept in different conditions.
So, fine wines, unlike most foods or drinks, get better when they age, at least up to a point. To say something, or someone, has aged like a fine wine is to say that they have improved with age.
To add to the existing excellent answer from Mixolydian, you may also be interested in the ultimate origin of fine. Etymologists don't seem to be 100% sure, but it seems to come from the same Latin root as finished, and was originally meant as complete, well-rounded, or indeed well-finished.
"Fine wine" typically means the best sorts of wine, though exactly what that means is subjective - though wine critics largely agree in practice. It also means they will be more expensive. I have heard it said that a truly fine wine is such a different experience from a typical supermarket wine that they do not really compare, not any more than wine to grape juice. I have never had what anyone would call a fine wine - and fine wines tend to be red more often than white, in my limited experience, so my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine. I did once have a wine that was supermarket price, but superior to anything I've had before or since - including the next year's vintage from the same vineyard. If that's one tenth of the difference between typical wines and fine wines, then I can see why people pay a lot of money for them.
Whatever it is that makes a wine "fine" also tends to affect how it develops after bottling. Wines being produced for the supermarket or local wine shop are intended to be drunk after a short, set aging period, and are as good as they will get when you buy them - and after a few years, they will degrade. Wines that are being made to be as good as they can get them take far longer to "peak" - to reach their optimum drinking quality. Wine buffs even put a lot of effort into working out when it will be, or knowing when it has happened so they can drink it as soon after peaking as possible. Of course, one bottle won't age the same as another if they are kept in different conditions.
So, fine wines, unlike most foods or drinks, get better when they age, at least up to a point. To say something, or someone, has aged like a fine wine is to say that they have improved with age.
answered 11 hours ago
SamBCSamBC
9,5661235
9,5661235
"my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine" Well, it is common when tasting wine to spit it out.
– Acccumulation
8 hours ago
You can't properly appreciate a wine just by tasting it. Plus some would get swallowed, it's inevitable.
– SamBC
7 hours ago
add a comment |
"my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine" Well, it is common when tasting wine to spit it out.
– Acccumulation
8 hours ago
You can't properly appreciate a wine just by tasting it. Plus some would get swallowed, it's inevitable.
– SamBC
7 hours ago
"my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine" Well, it is common when tasting wine to spit it out.
– Acccumulation
8 hours ago
"my opportunities to do so are limited by the fact that red wine gives me a migraine" Well, it is common when tasting wine to spit it out.
– Acccumulation
8 hours ago
You can't properly appreciate a wine just by tasting it. Plus some would get swallowed, it's inevitable.
– SamBC
7 hours ago
You can't properly appreciate a wine just by tasting it. Plus some would get swallowed, it's inevitable.
– SamBC
7 hours ago
add a comment |
This seems to be a pretty complicated question. Most wines actually don't age well at all. Only some wines age well, and it's not really true that wines that are more expensive before they are aged are the ones that age better. The aging process itself is expensive, so aged wines don't necessarily cost more because of the costs of growing those varietals or costs of making the wine from the grapes, it's the aging itself that drives up the cost.
The other tricky aspect of this question is the word fine. It doesn't just mean "good", especially in the area of wine-making. There is a process that is sometimes done to wine called fining, which is adding any of several substances that captures certain solutes and suspended substances in the wine and causes them to precipitate out.
So is it really that wine that has been fined ages better? Well not so fast, because over fining of wine can make it age more poorly, since some of the solutes that would be caused to precipitate by fining, like tannins, contribute to improvement of the wine when it's aged.
Very few wines improve with age, but those that do can become far more subtle and complex than unaged single-varietal wines, and while blends can be much more complex than single-varietals, an aged wine can have flavors that don't seem to be present in any kind of unaged wine. Then again, wines that age well often aren't very good when they have not yet been aged. Would they be called "fine" as in "good" before they have been aged? Probably not. At the same time, wine that ages well and has been well-aged, can easily be some of the best wine, and it makes sense to call it "fine wine" after it's been aged.
One possibility is that the phrase is just poetry. "Fine" and "wine" rhyme - and "aged like fine wine" rolls off the tongue quite well. Or it could spring from a misunderstanding of what it means for a wine to age well or be well-suited for aging. Even wine aficionados don't all agree on what "fine wine" means.
add a comment |
This seems to be a pretty complicated question. Most wines actually don't age well at all. Only some wines age well, and it's not really true that wines that are more expensive before they are aged are the ones that age better. The aging process itself is expensive, so aged wines don't necessarily cost more because of the costs of growing those varietals or costs of making the wine from the grapes, it's the aging itself that drives up the cost.
The other tricky aspect of this question is the word fine. It doesn't just mean "good", especially in the area of wine-making. There is a process that is sometimes done to wine called fining, which is adding any of several substances that captures certain solutes and suspended substances in the wine and causes them to precipitate out.
So is it really that wine that has been fined ages better? Well not so fast, because over fining of wine can make it age more poorly, since some of the solutes that would be caused to precipitate by fining, like tannins, contribute to improvement of the wine when it's aged.
Very few wines improve with age, but those that do can become far more subtle and complex than unaged single-varietal wines, and while blends can be much more complex than single-varietals, an aged wine can have flavors that don't seem to be present in any kind of unaged wine. Then again, wines that age well often aren't very good when they have not yet been aged. Would they be called "fine" as in "good" before they have been aged? Probably not. At the same time, wine that ages well and has been well-aged, can easily be some of the best wine, and it makes sense to call it "fine wine" after it's been aged.
One possibility is that the phrase is just poetry. "Fine" and "wine" rhyme - and "aged like fine wine" rolls off the tongue quite well. Or it could spring from a misunderstanding of what it means for a wine to age well or be well-suited for aging. Even wine aficionados don't all agree on what "fine wine" means.
add a comment |
This seems to be a pretty complicated question. Most wines actually don't age well at all. Only some wines age well, and it's not really true that wines that are more expensive before they are aged are the ones that age better. The aging process itself is expensive, so aged wines don't necessarily cost more because of the costs of growing those varietals or costs of making the wine from the grapes, it's the aging itself that drives up the cost.
The other tricky aspect of this question is the word fine. It doesn't just mean "good", especially in the area of wine-making. There is a process that is sometimes done to wine called fining, which is adding any of several substances that captures certain solutes and suspended substances in the wine and causes them to precipitate out.
So is it really that wine that has been fined ages better? Well not so fast, because over fining of wine can make it age more poorly, since some of the solutes that would be caused to precipitate by fining, like tannins, contribute to improvement of the wine when it's aged.
Very few wines improve with age, but those that do can become far more subtle and complex than unaged single-varietal wines, and while blends can be much more complex than single-varietals, an aged wine can have flavors that don't seem to be present in any kind of unaged wine. Then again, wines that age well often aren't very good when they have not yet been aged. Would they be called "fine" as in "good" before they have been aged? Probably not. At the same time, wine that ages well and has been well-aged, can easily be some of the best wine, and it makes sense to call it "fine wine" after it's been aged.
One possibility is that the phrase is just poetry. "Fine" and "wine" rhyme - and "aged like fine wine" rolls off the tongue quite well. Or it could spring from a misunderstanding of what it means for a wine to age well or be well-suited for aging. Even wine aficionados don't all agree on what "fine wine" means.
This seems to be a pretty complicated question. Most wines actually don't age well at all. Only some wines age well, and it's not really true that wines that are more expensive before they are aged are the ones that age better. The aging process itself is expensive, so aged wines don't necessarily cost more because of the costs of growing those varietals or costs of making the wine from the grapes, it's the aging itself that drives up the cost.
The other tricky aspect of this question is the word fine. It doesn't just mean "good", especially in the area of wine-making. There is a process that is sometimes done to wine called fining, which is adding any of several substances that captures certain solutes and suspended substances in the wine and causes them to precipitate out.
So is it really that wine that has been fined ages better? Well not so fast, because over fining of wine can make it age more poorly, since some of the solutes that would be caused to precipitate by fining, like tannins, contribute to improvement of the wine when it's aged.
Very few wines improve with age, but those that do can become far more subtle and complex than unaged single-varietal wines, and while blends can be much more complex than single-varietals, an aged wine can have flavors that don't seem to be present in any kind of unaged wine. Then again, wines that age well often aren't very good when they have not yet been aged. Would they be called "fine" as in "good" before they have been aged? Probably not. At the same time, wine that ages well and has been well-aged, can easily be some of the best wine, and it makes sense to call it "fine wine" after it's been aged.
One possibility is that the phrase is just poetry. "Fine" and "wine" rhyme - and "aged like fine wine" rolls off the tongue quite well. Or it could spring from a misunderstanding of what it means for a wine to age well or be well-suited for aging. Even wine aficionados don't all agree on what "fine wine" means.
edited 6 hours ago
answered 8 hours ago
Todd WilcoxTodd Wilcox
933610
933610
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to English Language Learners Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fell.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f199686%2fwhat-exactly-is-the-meaning-of-fine-wine%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
"Fine" is used in the sense of "excellent" there. A fine wine is one that is exceptionally good.
– Robusto
14 hours ago
"fine wine" is more than £20 a bottle.
– Owain
13 hours ago
4
@Owain In undergrad, fine wine came in a bottle
– Punintended
10 hours ago
3
This is one of those words that can mean its near opposite depending on usage. Compare "This is a fine wine" to "This wine is fine". The first implies that it is of exceptional quality, while the second implies that it is merely acceptable. The English language is screwy that way.
– Darrel Hoffman
7 hours ago